Are “Free” One-Year Lender Buydowns Worth It? The Honest Answer for DMV Buyers
Are "Free" One-Year Lender Buydowns Worth It? The Honest Answer for DMV Buyers
By John Downs - Certified Mortgage Advisor
What Is a One-Year Temporary Mortgage Buydown?
A one-year mortgage buydown, often called a 1-0 buydown, is a temporary arrangement that knocks your interest rate down by exactly 1% for the first 12 months of your loan. It belongs to a broader family of temporary rate reductions, like the 2-1 or 3-2-1 buydowns, which offer short-term payment relief early on.
The mechanics are simple. When you buy your home, you lock in a permanent interest rate, or the note rate. Legally, you are responsible for that full payment. With a one-year temporary buydown, however, you only pay a reduced amount based on a mortgage rate 1% lower. The mortgage servicer automatically pulls the remaining difference from a buydown escrow account each month to subsidize the loan. After 12 months, the account is empty, and you step up to your permanent rate for the remaining 29 years.
The critical thing to understand is that the upfront cost of any temporary buydown is simply the exact sum of those monthly payment differences. The money has to come from somewhere, which brings us to the "free" pitch you see online. (Want to see the math on your own numbers? Try my temporary buydown calculator.)
Is a "Free" One-Year Lender Buydown Actually Free?
The short answer is no. There is no free money in the mortgage business. While lenders heavily market these as free perks to grab your attention, they are actually funding that escrow account using premium pricing.
In plain English, the mortgage company increases your permanent interest rate, takes that extra backend profit, and drops it into a temporary account to feed it back to you over time. They are just taking your own lender credit, wrapping it in a marketing bow, and forcing you to take it in monthly installments instead of handing it to you as hard cash on closing day.
Absorbing that upfront cost typically means choosing a permanent rate that is roughly 0.25% higher than a standard zero-point loan. To make an informed decision, you have to look at your real options side-by-side.
On a $600,000 loan, your choices for the exact same pool of money look like this:
| Option | Note Rate | Monthly Payment | How It Works |
|---|---|---|---|
| Standard Fixed | 7.125% | $4,042 | Your true baseline rate. No gimmicks. |
| Lender Buydown | 7.375% (1st year @ 6.375%) |
1st Yr = $3,743 Yrs 2–30 = $4,144 |
The higher rate's premium pricing funds your first-year discount. |
| Lender Credit | 7.375% | $4,144 | That same money, as hard cash at closing. |
Example for illustration on a $600,000 loan. Your rate and payment will depend on your credit, down payment, and loan program.
The takeaway: The Lender Buydown and the Lender Credit come from the exact same pool of money. The only question is whether you get it in monthly installments or as hard cash on closing day.
When Does a One-Year Buydown Actually Make Sense?
There is one scenario where a lender-funded one-year buydown is the right choice. That is when your seller is already paying all of your closing costs and you genuinely have no use for additional cash at closing.
To understand why this is so rare, you must understand seller contribution limits. Mortgage underwriting guidelines have caps for how much a seller can pay toward your costs:
| Loan Type | Maximum Seller Contribution |
|---|---|
| Conventional < 10% Down | Up to 3% of the sale price |
| Conventional ≥ 10% Down | Up to 6% of the sale price |
| FHA | Up to 6% of the sale price |
In our local markets, closing costs, including prepaids and escrows, are roughly 3.25% of the sale price in Washington, DC and Maryland counties like Montgomery or Prince George's, while dropping closer to 2.25% in Northern Virginia areas like Fairfax and Arlington due to differences in how recordation taxes and property tax escrows are structured.
That means a first-time buyer putting 5% down on a conventional loan in Maryland has a 3% seller cap and 3.25% in closing costs. The seller credit cannot even fully cover the closing costs, let alone fund a buydown. The pitch does not apply to this buyer no matter how it is presented.
The Virginia Edge Case
Virginia creates one of the few real edge cases. Say a seller is giving you a 3% credit on the sale price. Closing costs only take 2.25%, leaving 0.75% of unused credit. That 0.75% is roughly the cost of a one-year buydown.
Now imagine you have a car payment with about a year left, and you think you will refinance at some point in the next few years. Using that leftover seller credit to fund a one-year buydown gives you payment relief during the year you are still carrying the car payment. By the time the buydown expires and your payment jumps, the car is paid off, and you may already be looking at a refinance. That is a real strategic use, not a marketing pitch.
For everyone else, you almost always have closing costs left to absorb the credit, and you are better off taking it as cash at closing.
What Happens If You Refinance Early?
This is the critical detail almost nobody explains in their marketing pitches.
Seller-Paid Buydown
If you refinance before the buydown term ends, any remaining escrow funds apply directly to your principal balance. You do not lose that money.
Lender-Paid Buydown
The remaining funds go right back to the lender. It doesn't refund to your principal, and it certainly doesn't get mailed back to you as a check.
In a fast-moving housing market where many buyers reasonably expect to refinance within the next 12 to 24 months, that matters significantly. If interest rates drop broadly and you jump into a refinance in month 8, the lender quietly pocketing the last 4 months of your buydown funds is a detail the slick ads conveniently leave out.
What Happens If You Don't Refinance?
Now let's look at the other side of that same coin. What happens if you take a higher permanent note rate today just to fund a temporary one-year patch, assuming you'll just break up with that rate in a year?
If you bought a home over the last few years, you probably heard the smooth pitch: "Take this one-year buydown. It's the perfect bridge to get you through today's high rates until you refinance next year." It sounded great in a sales presentation. But look at what actually happened to the buyers who took that bet in 2023 or 2024. They traded away a lower permanent note rate for 12 months of temporary relief. Now, years later, many of those same borrowers are still stuck holding that higher permanent rate because market cycles didn't play out on a neat schedule.
The hard truth about a temporary buydown, or paying upfront discount points, or taking a lender closing cost credit, is that you don't actually know the true cost of that financial decision until the day you pay the loan off. A mortgage refinance isn't an automatic guarantee. Life happens, and the landscape changes:
If you take a higher interest rate today to fund a one-year patch, you are gambling on an unknown future. If you get stuck in that loan for the long haul, that "free" bridge ends up costing you tens of thousands of dollars more over the life of your mortgage.
Why Is This Being Marketed So Aggressively?
This is the same dynamic I wrote about in my post on paying points. It is marketing math, not financial math.
A "free one-year buydown" sounds compelling. A "lender credit to cover your closing costs" sounds boring. They are the same money. But the buydown version gives the loan officer something interesting to say to a real estate agent, and it gives the agent something interesting to say to a buyer. That is the whole reason it exists as a marketing product.
Pro Tip: Ask any lender, "Can you show me the same loan with the buydown funds converted to a lender credit at closing instead?"
If they will not show you that comparison, you have your answer about whose interests are being served.
The Bottom Line for DMV Buyers
A one-year lender-funded buydown is a real product with a real, narrow use case. It is not a scam. It is not always bad.
But it should only be used when your seller is already covering all of your closing costs and you have no other use for the credit. Otherwise, take the lender credit and apply it to your closing costs. You will be better off on day one, and you will not lose the money if you refinance early.
To be clear, we do lender-funded buydowns at the Downs Group when they make sense. The reason I am writing this is not because we cannot offer them. It is because the typical pitch leaves out the option that is usually better for the buyer, and you deserve to see both sides.
If you are in DC, Maryland, or Virginia and want a real conversation about your options, reach out. We will run the numbers honestly, and you will see all the choices, not just the one with the best marketing pitch.
Offered a “Free” Buydown? Let's Run It Both Ways.
Before you accept a buydown offer, we can price both options side by side: the lower permanent rate and the temporary buydown. It takes minutes, and you will see exactly what the first year saves versus what the next 29 years cost.
Still comparing loan options? Start with our calculators →
